20 Best Thanksgiving Dessert Recipes

Are you looking for some delicious and easy desserts to make for Thanksgiving? If so, you’re in luck! In this article, I will share with you 20 of the best Thanksgiving dessert recipes that will impress your family and friends.

These recipes are not only mouthwatering, but also simple to follow. You’ll find classic pies, such as pumpkin, apple, and pecan, as well as some creative twists, such as cheesecakes, cupcakes, and cake rolls.

Whether you prefer something traditional or something new, you’ll find something to suit your taste buds.

So, without further ado, let’s dive into these 20 amazing Thanksgiving dessert recipes that will make your holiday sweeter than ever!

Quick answer: The best Thanksgiving desserts balance one classic pie with one make-ahead, oven-free option. This list of 20 ideas covers pumpkin pies, cheesecakes, chocolate and pecan bakes, plus no-bake and bar options that can be chilled ahead, so the oven stays free for the main meal. Pick one pumpkin pie, one chocolate or pecan bake, and one chilled dessert, and the table is covered without baking everything on the day.

1. Pumpkin Custard Pie

Thanksgiving Dessert

A custard-style pumpkin pie is a softer, silkier take on the classic slice, and it suits a table where pumpkin pie is expected but a lighter finish is welcome. Bake it the day before if the linked recipe allows, chill it until serving time, and keep one oven shelf free on the day for dishes that must be served hot.

2. No-Bake Pumpkin Cheesecake

No-bake is the key advantage here: this idea frees the oven entirely on Thanksgiving Day, which matters when the turkey and sides are competing for space. Chill it ahead in the fridge, add any topping just before serving, and slice it cold so each piece holds its shape on the plate.

3. Pumpkin Cake with Cream Cheese Frosting

Thanksgiving Dessert

A pumpkin cake serves a crowd more easily than individual slices of pie, since it can be cut into generous squares for a buffet-style dessert table. Bake the cake ahead and frost it closer to serving so the frosting stays fresh, and keep it covered in a cool spot rather than stacking other dishes on top of it.

4. Gluten-Free Crustless Pumpkin Pie

Thanksgiving Dessert

As the title promises, this is a gluten-free, crustless idea, so it suits a guest who avoids gluten without needing a separate crust to be made. Skipping the crust also saves a step on a busy baking day. Check the linked recipe for its full ingredient list, and label the dish clearly at the table so guests can spot it easily.

5. Vegan Pumpkin Donuts

These donuts are presented as vegan in the linked idea, which makes them a useful option for a guest who avoids dairy and eggs. Donuts also break up a dessert table full of pies and cakes, and they are easy for children to pick up. Bake them the day before if the recipe allows, and glaze or dust them just before serving.

6. Pumpkin Bars

Thanksgiving Dessert

Bars are the practical choice for a large gathering: they bake in one pan, cut into even portions, and travel well to a potluck or a second celebration. They also stack neatly in a container for the fridge, so leftovers stay tidy. Serve them at room temperature, and cut them only once they have cooled and set.

7. Pumpkin Spice Latte Cookies

These cookies borrow the spiced coffee-shop flavour many guests already love, so they feel festive without needing a whole new dessert. Cookies are easy to bake ahead, keep well in a sealed container, and pack into a tin for gifting. Bake a generous batch if you want some for the table and some to send home with guests.

8. Pumpkin Roll with Orange Cream Cheese

Thanksgiving Dessert

A pumpkin roll looks impressive on the table but slices into neat portions, which helps when dessert needs to stretch across a large guest list. The orange cream cheese filling gives it a brighter flavour than a plain pumpkin cake. Roll and chill it ahead of time, and slice it with a clean, sharp knife so the spiral shows.

9. Pumpkin Pie Cupcakes

Thanksgiving Dessert

Cupcakes give each guest a ready portion, which suits a standing dessert table or a meal where guests serve themselves. The pumpkin-pie flavour keeps them firmly in Thanksgiving territory, while the cupcake format avoids the slicing and serving that a pie needs. Bake them ahead, top them near serving time, and keep them covered until dessert.

A cookie crust adds crunch and a little sweetness under a creamy pumpkin cheesecake, and cheesecake is a natural make-ahead dessert because it needs chilling time to set. Make it the day before, keep it in the fridge, and slice it cold. It suits a table that already has a traditional pumpkin pie, since it offers a different texture rather than a repeat.

11. Chocolate Pecan Pie With Bourbon

Thanksgiving Dessert

Bourbon is named in the title, so this pie is aimed at adults who enjoy that deeper, warming flavour alongside chocolate and pecan. It is a rich slice, so smaller portions go a long way after a heavy meal. Bake it ahead if the linked recipe allows, cool it fully before covering, and check the recipe if you need to know how the bourbon is used.

12. French Chocolate Mousse

Mousse is a lighter, spoonable dessert after a heavy Thanksgiving meal, and it needs no oven time at all. Make it ahead and chill it in individual dishes or one large bowl, so the fridge does the work while the oven stays free. Serve it cold, in small portions, since a little goes a long way after pie.

13. Chocolate Pecan Pie

Thanksgiving Dessert

This is the chocolate-and-pecan pie without the bourbon named in the neighbouring idea, so it is the simpler pick for a mixed-age table. Pecan pie holds its shape well once cooled, which makes slicing straightforward. Bake it the day before, store it covered as the linked recipe directs, and warm individual slices only if guests ask.

14. White Chocolate Cranberry Fudge with Almonds

Fudge is a make-ahead gift as much as a dessert: it sets in the fridge, cuts into small squares, and packs neatly into a tin. The white chocolate, cranberry and almond combination adds colour and crunch to a dessert table. Cut it into small pieces, since fudge is sweet and rich, and keep it cool until serving so it stays firm.

15. Chocolate Cranberry Brownies

Brownies are easy to scale for a crowd, since one pan cuts into as many pieces as the guest list needs, and they suit guests who want chocolate rather than pie. Bake them ahead, cool them completely before cutting, and store them covered. They also travel well, so a second pan can go to a neighbour or a potluck without extra packaging.

16. Chocolate Cream Pie

A cream pie offers a cool, soft contrast to the baked pies elsewhere in this list, and it can be chilled ahead while the oven is busy with savoury dishes. Keep it in the fridge until dessert, and slice it cold so the filling holds. It suits guests who prefer chocolate to pumpkin, and it rounds out a dessert table without needing another hot oven slot.

17. Chocolate Pecan Pie

Thanksgiving Dessert

A second chocolate pecan pie idea is worth keeping in the list because the linked recipes differ even when the titles sound alike, so compare them before choosing. Pick the one whose crust, filling and sweetness level match your table, and bake it ahead to free Thanksgiving Day for reheating sides. Serve small slices: pecan pie is rich, and most guests will want a taste rather than a large portion.

18. Pecan Pie Cheesecake Bars

Thanksgiving Dessert

Bars combine two dessert ideas in one pan, which is handy when the table is already full of whole pies. They cut into even, easy-to-serve squares, chill well in the fridge, and suit a buffet where guests help themselves. Make them the day before, slice them cold, and keep them covered until they are set out.

19. Gluten-Free Pecan Pie

Thanksgiving Dessert

This pecan pie is presented as gluten-free, so it lets a guest who avoids gluten join in the most traditional Thanksgiving dessert without a separate bake. Read the linked recipe carefully for its crust and filling, since gluten-free bakes can differ in texture from a standard pie. Bake it ahead, label it at the table, and keep it on its own plate so it is easy to identify.

20. Maple Pecan Butter Tarts

Thanksgiving Dessert

Butter tarts are small, individual desserts, which makes portion control easy and avoids the slicing a large pie needs. The maple and pecan flavours fit the season, and the tarts travel well in a container. Bake them ahead if the recipe allows, cool them fully, and set out a full plate: guests tend to take one, then return for a second.

You have reached the end of this article on 20 Best Thanksgiving Dessert Recipes. We hope you enjoyed reading about these delicious treats and found some inspiration for your own holiday menu.

Whether you prefer pies, cakes, cheesecakes, or cookies, there is something for everyone in this list. Try one or more of these recipes and share your feedback with us in the comments below.

Thank you for choosing our website as your source of Thanksgiving dessert ideas. Have a wonderful and sweet Thanksgiving!

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I make Thanksgiving desserts ahead of time?

Yes, and most of the ideas in this list are easier when some of the work happens the day before. Chilled desserts such as cheesecake and mousse need fridge time to set, and pies can be baked ahead and stored as the linked recipe directs. Leave frosting and delicate toppings until closer to serving, so they still look fresh when the dessert table is set out.

How do I fit dessert baking around the turkey?

Start with the desserts that need no oven at all, such as the no-bake cheesecake and the mousse, and bake the pies the day before if the linked recipe allows it. On Thanksgiving Day, the oven belongs to the turkey and the hot sides, so a dessert that only needs the fridge is a genuine help. A dessert table with one baked pie, one chilled dessert and one batch of bars covers the table without a last-minute bake.

What desserts work for guests with dietary needs?

This list names a gluten-free crustless pumpkin pie, a vegan pumpkin donut idea and a gluten-free pecan pie in their titles, so those are the natural starting points. Always read the full linked recipe before serving, since titles alone do not list every ingredient, and label each dish at the table. If you are unsure about an ingredient, ask the guest rather than guessing from the title.

How many desserts should I make for a crowd?

Two or three different desserts are usually plenty, especially when each one is served in small portions. A whole pie, a chilled dessert and a tray of bars or cupcakes gives guests a real choice without leaving a mountain of leftovers. Scale the bars and cupcakes to the guest list, since they are the easiest desserts in this list to cut into more, or fewer, portions.

How should I store leftover Thanksgiving desserts?

Cover leftovers and refrigerate anything with cream, cheesecake or mousse filling, and follow the storage guidance in the linked recipe for baked pies and bars. Keep different desserts in separate containers so flavours do not transfer, and label anything that is gluten-free or vegan. Most leftovers are best eaten within a few days, while the texture is still at its best.

Complete the Table

Round out the menu with vegetarian Thanksgiving desserts, Thanksgiving cookies, Thanksgiving cupcakes, vegetarian Thanksgiving main dishes, and Thanksgiving side dishes.

Mittu

Posts on leafline.us are published under the byline Mittu. The blog covers crafts, nail designs and vegetarian-first recipes, planned around the US seasonal calendar.

More Reading

Post navigation

2 Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *